I think it’s obvious by now I still like Homura after the events of Rebellion. So maybe just maybe she is able to find happiness off screen/off pages after Rebellion. I like to think they have a happy ending eventually because I love these characters and I want them all to be happy. Yet by the end of Rebellion she thinks she doesn’t deserve Madoka’s friendship and so she gives those ribbons back. She’ll do anything for Madoka, but by the same token, she will do anything to get to be with her one and only friend. Homura’s problem is that she trusts no one’s judgment but her own, she is EXCEEDINGLY stubborn, and really, she is realistically selfish. It seems to me she is just playing the villain part because she thinks she’s supposed to.like a “well if everyone else thinks I am then fine, I’m a monster evil thing”.but she has really hurt no one except herself with any of her actual actions. She has done some WRONG things but that doesn’t make her evil.

I think she sees herself as a horrible thing (hence giving Madoka the ribbons back at the end😭) and she’s a little “off” mentally (who wouldn’t be, the girl should be insane at this point), but I don’t think Homura has done anything downright villainous. Now the real question.did Homura really turn evil? I think not. Kyubey totally deserves to have to take on allllll the despair and curses he and his little fuzzball aliens were giving to the magical girls. Dark Homura can just torture them all she likes for all I care, good for her. Lol and Kyubey and the other Incubators but I couldn’t care less about those little greedy nasty creeps. Everyone is happy in Homura’s new altered world.except poor Homura herself.

Download free madoka magica movie 2